Call to the Public

Constitution over party

Apparently, we’re doing the homework.

Prescott Valley’s surveillance story, with the paperwork.

See the PV timeline
Satirical illustration: George Washington hands his beer tankard to Benjamin Franklin while removing a surveillance camera. Red, white and blue colonial street scene.

Prescott Valley, Arizona

Follow the paper trail.

The agenda title. The action taken. The record you can read for yourself.

New since the July 13 notice

This label marks details added after the July 13 notice to the Town. The date on each entry still shows when the event happened or the document was written.

Jump to the July 13 timeline entry
Read the news and original sources

Each meeting shows the full item title and a separate action taken. The linked record identifies the source. Votes are shown where verified. Notices, contracts and other dates use document titles because they are not Council agenda items. Red arrow notes are our commentary.

Updated October 4, 2026

2023

  1. Council budget retreat

    Cameras enter the budget conversation.

    Agenda title · Item 2aMeeting agenda
    FY23/24 Town Council Budget Retreat - Discussion Only [Gilbert Davidson, Town Manager]
    Our take

    Cameras at the park. Tucked into a budget retreat.

    Action taken
    Budget discussion only

    Staff presented future budget priorities, including more cameras and plate readers at Mountain Valley Park. The minutes record planning discussion, with no camera purchase motion.

    Council minutes

    The Town’s planning material already names additional cameras and license plate readers at Mountain Valley Park. This predates the August pilot grant vote.

  2. Council budget study session

    $31,000 shows up in the budget.

    Agenda title · Item 2aMeeting agenda
    Fiscal Year 2023-24 Budget Review (Discussion) [Katie Pehl, Finance Director]
    Our take

    The camera line is on the slide. Bring a magnifying glass.

    Action taken
    Discussion only · No action requested

    Staff presented the preliminary budget. The completed report lists Council action as N/A and says additional input would go into the later tentative budget approval.

    Staff report and action field

    The police budget slide lists “License Plate Readers & Software” at $31,000. The meeting is a budget review, with no action requested on this item.

  3. Council vote

    It starts as a 12 month pilot.

    Agenda title · Item 8bStaff report
    Grant Award Department of Emergency and Military Affairs - Consideration & Possible Action (Approve) [Robert Ticer, Chief of Police]
    Our take

    “Grant Award.” Where does this say cameras?

    Action taken
    Approved · 5 to 0, with 2 absent

    Schumacher moved and Dickinson seconded authorization for the Mayor to sign Resolution 2023-2335 approving the $256,791.26 DEMA grant agreement. The presentation described the LPR program as a 12 month pilot.

    Motion and vote in the minutes

    Council approves a $256,791.26 grant covering plate readers and drones. The minutes describe the plate reader program as a 12 month pilot. The vote passes with 5 in favor and 2 absent.

2024

  1. Signed agreement
    New since the July 13 notice

    The signed agreement adds the contract price, terms and signature dates to the record assembled after the July 13 notice.

    15 plate readers are ordered.

    Document titleFlock Safety agreement
    EXHIBIT A · ORDER FORM
    Action taken
    Agreement signed by both parties

    Town Manager Gilbert Davidson signed on January 23. Flock General Counsel Mark Smith signed on January 30.

    Dated signatures on page 9

    The signed Flock order lists 15 Falcon plate readers, $45,000 in annual charges, and a $55,750 first year subtotal before tax. The order appears on page 7.

  2. Council study session

    Plate readers enter the discussion.

    Agenda title · Item 2aCouncil minutes
    Big Leadership Report Update – Discussion Only [Robert Ticer, Police Chief]
    Our take

    Plate readers made the minutes. Good luck finding them in that title.

    Action taken
    Presentation and discussion only

    Council heard the police leadership update and asked questions. The minutes record discussion of license plate readers and the Crime View system, with no camera purchase motion or vote.

    Discussion in the minutes

    Councilmember Dickinson mentions license plate readers during a broader police leadership update. Police staff also discuss the Crime View system and crime and traffic reporting.

  3. Council minutes approval

    The discussion becomes an approved record.

    Agenda title · Item 8aMeeting agenda
    Study Session Meeting Minutes of February 1, 2024 - Consideration & Possible Action (Approve) [Fatima Fernandez, Town Clerk]
    Action taken
    February 1 minutes approved

    The completed staff report records approval of the February 1 study session minutes. This action approves the meeting record; it does not authorize a new camera purchase.

    Completed staff report

    The approved minutes preserve the February 1 discussion of license plate readers and crime data. The approval appears under consent agenda item 8a.

  4. Deployment

    The first cameras go live.

    Slide titleTown presentation · June 5, 2025
    Flock at Prescott Valley
    Action taken
    First 15 plate readers deployed

    The Town’s later presentation identifies May 2024 as the deployment month. It does not give a specific day.

    Deployment slide dated June 5, 2025

    The Town’s June 2025 presentation dates the deployment of the first 15 plate readers to May 2024, covering vehicles entering and leaving Prescott Valley.

  5. Signed agreement and internal approvals
    New since the July 13 notice

    The signed order and internal review sheet add details about who reviewed this purchase. These documents were not part of the July notice.

    5 more cameras. 4 internal signoffs.

    Document titleTown routing sheet and Flock order
    Agreement & Contract Tracking Cover Sheet
    Action taken
    Internal reviews completed and agreement signed

    The department head, Finance, Legal and Town Manager signed the routing sheet on June 28. Gilbert Davidson and Flock’s Mark Smith also signed the order that day.

    Approvals on page 1 · Contract signatures on page 7

    The order adds 5 Falcon plate readers at $15,000 in annual recurring charges. The routing sheet identifies the officer safety account and marks the purchase as budgeted for FY25.

  6. Signed agreement
    New since the July 13 notice

    The signed agreement adds the park camera equipment, software and contract terms to the later record. The July notice requested the contracts behind the program.

    Live video joins the program.

    Document titlePark camera agreement
    Flock Safety + AZ - Prescott Valley PD
    Action taken
    Park camera agreement signed

    Town Manager Gilbert Davidson and Flock General Counsel Mark Smith signed the agreement on September 26.

    Dated signatures on page 5

    The Mountain Valley Park agreement adds 6 combined plate reader and video units, 2 cameras that can pan, tilt and zoom, 4 video gateways, and FlockOS Elite software. It lists $40,000 in annual recurring charges.

  7. Invoice approval
    New since the July 13 notice

    The July notice already identified the $49,954 payment. The invoice and November 4 approval shown here add the itemized charges and approval record.

    The park camera bill: $49,954.

    Document titleFlock invoice and Town purchase order
    INVOICE · INV-48556
    Action taken
    Invoice approved for payment

    The invoice carries an “OK TO PAY” stamp dated November 4. The attached Town purchase order is dated October 31 and totals $49,954. The approval stamp does not establish the date funds were sent.

    Payment approval and purchase order

    The September 30 invoice itemizes plate readers, live video cameras, gateways and installation. The $46,282 subtotal plus $3,672 in sales tax brings the bill to $49,954.

2025

  1. Grant approval

    More cameras. More software.

    Agenda title · Item 8dMeeting agenda
    Department Public Safety Grant Award and Agreement, Local Border Support - Consideration & Possible Action to (Approve) [Robert L. Ticer, Chief of Police]
    Our take

    The title says border support. The packet says cameras.

    Action taken
    Grant agreement approved

    Council approved the $417,489 DPS Local Border Support grant agreement. The completed staff report records the Council action as approved.

    Completed staff report

    An approved $417,489 grant includes $46,872 for plate readers and $21,964 for real time software connecting Town and park cameras. The staff report says future operating costs could rely on grants, opioid funds, or other funding, including the General Fund.

  2. Council study session

    No vote on surveillance.

    Agenda title · Item 2bMeeting agenda
    License Plate Reader Presentation - Consideration & Possible Action to (Review) [Presenter - Assistant Chief James Edelstein]
    Our take

    A presentation is not a vote. Council did not vote to approve or expand the program under this item.

    Action taken
    No vote taken on item 2b

    Council heard the presentation and asked questions, but did not vote on this item. The staff report says ‘Discussion Only’ and ‘No Action Requested’ and lists Council action as ‘N/A.’

    Read the discussion in the minutes

    PVPD reports 26 active plate readers, 6 live view cameras, and about $152,000 in annual costs. The minutes also describe a planned platform to connect camera systems and potential access to business and HOA cameras.

2026

  1. Consent agenda grant approval

    The grant has software in the attachments.

    Agenda title · Item 8cMeeting agenda
    2025 Department of Public Safety/Anti-Human Trafficking Grant Award and Agreement - Consideration & Possible Action (Approve) [Robert L. Ticer, Police Chief]
    Our take

    “Grant Award.” Please enjoy the software in the attachments.

    Action taken
    $88,588.76 grant agreement approved

    The completed staff report records approval of the DPS grant agreement for criminal justice software and AI enhancement software. It also identifies opioid funds for remaining software costs.

    Completed staff report

    The packet includes a Peregrine quote connecting multiple data sources, including limited Flock ALPR access, and an Axon quote. The staff report discusses Axon Draft One. These quotes describe proposed products and scope; they do not establish that every quoted feature was purchased or deployed. This is 1 of the agenda notices challenged in the July Open Meeting Law complaint.

  2. Consent agenda policy vote

    Council puts 8 police policies to a vote.

    The resolution identifies 8 police policies by number and title. None of those titles identifies a license plate reader policy. The vote should not be described as approval of every policy in the police manual.

  3. Consent agenda grant actions

    The grant paperwork keeps moving.

    Agenda title · Item 8dMeeting agenda
    Budget Adjustment 2025 Department of Public Safety (DPS) Local Border Support Grant – Consideration & Possible Action (Approve) [Police Chief Robert Ticer]
    Action taken
    Approved · 7 to 0

    Council approved the grant budget adjustment in the consent motion covering items 8a, 8b, 8d and 8e. Zurcher moved and Lopez seconded.

    Motion and vote in the minutes
    Agenda title · Item 8eMeeting agenda
    First Amendment, Intergovernmental Agreement (IGA 2025-061) with Arizona Department of Public Safety (DPS) re Local Border Support Grant – Consideration & Possible Action (Authorize Signature) [Robert Ticer, Police Chief]
    Action taken
    Signature authorized · 7 to 0

    The same consent motion approved authorization to sign the amendment to IGA 2025-061, the Local Border Support grant agreement approved in March 2025.

    Motion and vote in the minutes

    Council takes 2 further actions on grant funding: a budget adjustment and an agreement amendment. The separate Flock contract signed on March 12 and 13 appears next in the timeline.

  4. Signed agreement
    New since the July 13 notice

    The $131,250 agreement and emails about Finance and Legal were added after the July notice. March 12 and 13 are the signature dates. The records were obtained later.

    A $131,250 commitment.

    Document titleSigned agreement · Q-187512
    Flock Safety + AZ - Prescott Valley PD
    Action taken
    Signed by both parties

    Town Manager Gilbert Davidson signs on March 12. Dan Haley, Flock’s legal officer, signs for the company on March 13.

    Dated signatures · Page 7

    The Town signs a 3 year, $131,250 deal with Flock, before tax. It includes FlockOS Plus software, 2 packages of plate readers and video cameras, and connections to 5 community cameras. The contract number is Q-187512.

  5. Contract email correspondence
    New since the July 13 notice

    This Finance email was added to the evidence after the July notice. March 27 is the date of the email, not the date it was obtained.

    2 weeks after signing, Finance has a question.

    Document titleEmail chain · Finance question and Flock response
    Re: FW: FW: Wednesday Updates: Flock Proposal + Camera Map
    Action taken
    Finance asks for a correction · Flock replies

    Finance asks Flock to add the missing number of an earlier purchasing agreement. Flock says that agreement already covers this deal. The email does not include a Town response accepting that answer.

    Question and reply · Page 1

    The signed deal is missing a reference to an earlier purchasing agreement through Tempe, number T21-119-1. Finance asks for it to be added. Flock replies that the new deal already uses the earlier agreement’s terms.

  6. July 13: the original notice to the Town
    Written notice to the Town

    Put the request in writing.

    Document titleWritten notice · Laura Covell
    Request for a publicly noticed hearing and recorded vote on the Town’s Flock Safety surveillance camera and license plate tracking program (the automated license plate reader / Real-Time Operations program); Arizona public records request under A.R.S. §§ 39-121 et seq.; and demand for preservation of records

    A written notice asks the Town for a publicly noticed hearing, a recorded Council vote, the records behind the surveillance program, and preservation of those records. The letter is dated July 12 and signed July 13. The Clerk confirms receipt on July 14. Document downloads are temporarily unavailable.

  7. Public records production
    New since the July 13 notice

    The log was supplied July 21, 8 days after the notice. The portal later lists August 4 as the request’s completion date.

    A search log. What about the requested records?

    Record namePublic records production
    PD-2026-280 search activity log

    The Town supplies a 56 page search log on July 21 under PD-2026-280. The requests sought records about a specific vehicle, plus contracts, authorization and other program records. The Town combined requests under PD-2026-280. The portal later lists that request as completed on August 4.

  8. Open Meeting Law complaint
    After the notice

    The complaint goes to the Attorney General.

    Document titleComplaint by Laura Covell · Subject line
    Signed written complaint under A.R.S. §§ 38-431 to 38-431.09 — Town of Prescott Valley Town Council — agenda items that did not disclose the matters to be decided

    An Open Meeting Law complaint is filed with the Arizona Attorney General’s Open Meeting Law Enforcement Team, known as OMLET. It challenges the agenda notices for March 13, 2025 and January 22, 2026, and asks the office to investigate and determine whether the notices complied with the law. The Attorney General acknowledges the complaint on August 6. Document downloads are temporarily unavailable.

  9. Council meeting
    After the notice

    The public asks for a vote.

    Agenda title · Item 3Council minutes
    CALL TO THE PUBLIC
    Our take

    The public called. It asked for a vote.

    Action taken
    Public comments received

    Speakers raised surveillance concerns. Freund expressed support for putting the matter on a future agenda. The minutes record no program approval under this item.

    Public comment and Council response
    Agenda title · Item 4cCouncil minutes
    Opioid Settlement Fund Checks in the amount of $15,290.03 and $3,403.36 from Yavapai County Community Health Services - Consideration & Possible Action (Approve) [Robert L. Ticer, Police Chief]
    Action taken
    Approved · 7 to 0

    Schumacher moved and Greer seconded applying $18,693.39 to narcotics enforcement education, equipment and software, with the corresponding budget adjustment. Ticer said there were no plans to use these funds for plate readers.

    Motion and vote in the minutes

    Public comment calls for a clearly announced surveillance vote and a record of how each Council member votes. Council also approves $18,693.39 in opioid settlement funds. Chief Ticer says there are no plans to use those funds for plate readers.

  10. Deadline and Council appearance
    After the notice

    The statutory ratification deadline.

    Agenda title · Item 5Meeting agenda
    CALL TO THE PUBLIC
    Our take

    The public brought a calendar.

    Action taken
    Public comment received

    Public comment called for ratification. The published agenda lists this as Call to the Public and contains no ALPR ratification item.

    Town meeting video · 25:50

    Public comment identifies August 13 as the 30 day ratification deadline under A.R.S. §38-431.05(B)(1), counting from the Clerk’s confirmed July 14 receipt of the written notice. The Town is asked to identify any different discovery date and its legal basis. The applicable discovery date remains an issue in the Open Meeting Law complaint.

  11. Council appearance
    After the notice

    Back at the microphone.

    Agenda title · Item 6Meeting agenda
    CALL TO THE PUBLIC
    Our take

    Same questions. Another meeting.

    Action taken
    Ratification and records requested again

    Public comment again raised ratification and outstanding surveillance records. The remarks are linked to the meeting video; the published agenda contains no ALPR ratification item.

    Town meeting video · 36:34
    Agenda title · Item 9aMeeting agenda
    Special Town Council Meeting Minutes of August 6, 2026 - Consideration & Possible Action (Approve) [Fatima Fernandez, Town Clerk]
    Action taken
    August 6 minutes approved

    The completed staff report marks the August 6 minutes approved. This action approves the meeting record; it is not a separate vote authorizing the surveillance program.

    Completed staff report

    Public comment again raises ratification, outstanding audit and usage logs, and continued surveillance while authorization and transparency questions remain unresolved. Council also approves the August 6 meeting minutes under item 9a.

  12. Public opinion survey
    After the notice

    The PV poll is published.

    NextGen Polling releases the privately commissioned Prescott Valley survey on police use of Flock cameras, public approval, and independent audits. The linked release contains the results and survey details.

  13. Council appearance
    After the notice

    Another Call to the Public.

    Agenda title · Item 6Meeting agenda
    CALL TO THE PUBLIC
    Our take

    Still calling. Still keeping the receipts.

    Action taken
    Public comment received

    The campaign organizer confirms speaking at this meeting. The agenda identifies the public comment period as item 6. It does not list an ALPR approval or ratification item.

    Published meeting agenda

    The September 24 regular Council meeting follows the September 21 release of the Prescott Valley poll on police use of Flock cameras, public approval, and independent audits.

  14. Records request announcement
    After the notice

    Goldwater asks for the records.

    Goldwater Institute names Prescott Valley among the agencies receiving its records requests. It seeks contracts, camera locations, retention policies, sharing agreements, and rules for searching the data.

  15. Council study session
    New since the July 13 notice

    The Town's presentation listing 798 agencies came after the July notice. This later statement is being added to the record, not attributed to the original letter.

    798 agencies. Still a discussion.

    Agenda title · Item 2cMeeting agenda
    License Plate Reader (LPR) Presentation - Discussion Only [Robert Ticer, Police Chief and Jeremy Martin, Assistant Police Chief]
    Our take

    “Discussion Only.” The cameras aren’t just discussing.

    Action taken
    Presentation and public questions

    Police presented the program and answered questions from Council and the public. The item was designated discussion only. Public questions also addressed the broader connected camera system.

    Town meeting video · Presentation at 36:33

    The Town’s ALPR presentation lists 798 nationwide law enforcement agencies under data sharing, and the agenda labels the item “Discussion Only.” A written public submission calls for the records, a full independent audit, and a properly noticed Council decision with a recorded vote.

What we’re asking Prescott Valley to do

Put it on the agenda.
Take a public vote.

We’re asking what the cameras collect, who can access it, who approved the system, and how anyone checks the answers.

This campaign calls on Prescott Valley to end its ALPR and connected real time surveillance program through a clearly announced public discussion and a recorded Council vote.

We also want the records released, an independent audit of the connected systems and outside access, and a public explanation of termination and equipment removal costs.

Show your work

A few perfectly
reasonable questions.

The records explain how the program grew. These are the answers we’re still asking the Town to put on the record.

The signed agreements, approval records, agenda materials, and funding documents should show who authorized the program and its expansion.

Publish the documents. Let people follow the decision.

Start with the pilot approval

Why this exists

Public records.
Public accountability.

Prescott Valley deserves clear answers about the surveillance systems its government uses.

This timeline puts the records in one place so anyone can follow the decisions, ask questions, and speak up. It distinguishes unanswered questions from established facts and corrects errors.

Organized by Laura Covell, a small business owner in Prescott Valley, Arizona.

Get PV updates